You Might Be the Family Scapegoat if…

• You feel like the black sheep in your family.
• You are blamed for problems that were never fully yours.
• Your mistakes are remembered longer than anyone else’s.
• Your successes are minimized, ignored, or picked apart.
• You feel emotionally excluded from your own family.
• You learned to stay quiet, shrink yourself, or over-explain to avoid criticism.
• You feel responsible for keeping the peace, even when you are hurting too. 
• You constantly feel misunderstood by the people closest to you.

You were often overlooked, ignored. Even your successes were brushed aside. You took the blame — for everything — even when it wasn’t your fault. Maybe you learned to stay small. Maybe you leaned into the role they gave you: difficult, dramatic, broken, too much. Maybe part of you started believing it. If any of this sounds familiar, you may be the family scapegoat — and you are far from alone.

You were the Scapegoat. 

The family scapegoat — often called the problem child, the bad apple, or the black sheep — is the member of the family system who can do no right and always does wrong. The scapegoated child becomes the emotional dumping ground for the entire family, carrying blame so others do not have to face their own shame, guilt, or dysfunction.

Signs You Are the Family Scapegoat

In many ways, the Scapegoat is the opposite of the Golden Child. Where the Golden Child is looked upon with expectation, the Scapegoat is monitored with suspicion.

The Scapegoat is unfairly criticized more than any other family member [6]. They are often seen to not do much right. Their successes are often overlooked, or are picked apart. Their wins are taken from them. The Scapegoat is almost always cast in a negative light. The scapegoated child may also feel ignored by their family, even if it seems they have time for each other or people outside of the family system [5]. 

Rather than accountability being taken for the treatment of the Scapegoat or the things being blamed on them, the family often justifies the situation. Parents may find excuses as to why they have deemed one child the Scapegoat through evidence of past behaviors or mistakes [5].

The Emotional Weight of Being the Family Scapegoat

Being the Scapegoat can feel incredibly isolating. They are often blamed for all the problems going on at home: the arguments, the debt, or the mental health issues [2]. They take on all of the blame of hardship within the family system, giving others the space to not feel certain uncomfortable emotions, such as shame, blame, guilt, and inadequacy. This often leads to isolation or exclusion emotionally or physically from family activities, gatherings, or conversations [6]. Siblings may separate themselves from the Scapegoat in order to not be associated with the family shame, they may even join in on the blame. 

The Scapegoat often develops their own way of managing their situation–through humor or blunt honesty. Some Scapegoats survive by disconnecting from their emotions completely, while others feel everything intensely with no safe place to put them [2]. The Scapegoat is often left to cope on their own. This emotional abandonment and isolation can create emotional and social issues in the Scapegoat’s life as a child and through adulthood. They may act out or rebel, becoming the outcast their family treats them as [8]. 

Gaslighting is a common form of abuse toward the Scapegoat. Gaslighting is a form of psychological manipulation where the abuser distorts the reality of their victim to undermine their perception of truth [6]. In the case of scapegoating, the abuser may invalidate the Scapegoat’s experiences and emotions [6]. This leaves the Scapegoat to feel confused and vulnerable. 

How the Family Scapegoat Role Is Created

Dysfunctional Family Dynamics

Many who have unresolved trauma as part of their story will go on to reenact those damaging patterns in other relationships. That may be the case for family systems with scapegoating dynamics [6]. Along with this, unprocessed generational trauma can wreak havoc on family systems [4].

The Scapegoat is often selected when a family is unable to work through their problems through healthy patterns, such as communication or honesty [2]. In these families, communication is usually poor and conflicts often are left unresolved [6].

Instead, these dysfunctional families select one child and project their blame and distress onto them. The Scapegoat becomes the identified problem, something for the family to be able to fix instead of focusing on the actual issues [8]. This allows the family to seek a false sense of security or stability through maintaining “homeostasis.” [4].

Myth Busting: There is a common myth that all scapegoating happens in families that are led by a parent with narcissistic personality disorder or narcissistic tendencies. Keep in mind that family scapegoating is a mechanism of the system and not just a personality trait of a parent, sibling, or other family members [4]. 

Projection

Projection can be a large motivator for the presence of scapegoating behaviors in a dysfunctional family system. Projection occurs when family members assign their own unacceptable thoughts, feelings, or behaviors onto the Scapegoat [6]. Sometimes, parents will choose the scapegoated child based on similarities they may see in the child to their own perceived failures, slights, or insecurities–the parent may see all the things they don’t like about themselves in the scapegoated child [6].

In turn, the Scapegoat is groomed to accept all the responsibility of the family’s faults so that the abusers can escape the pain of these emotions [3, 7].

Weaponized Traits

The Scapegoat can be selected for a variety of reasons, but it is never the child’s fault. Whatever the reason, the characteristics observed in the Scapegoat were chosen out of someone else’s shame, not based on any actual deficiency in the child’s being.

The Scapegoat often has characteristics that make them stand out in their family unit, traits that the dysfunctional family weaponizes. The Scapegoat may be unique, threatening the family’s demand for conformity (e.g., neurodivergence, LGBTQ+, different political views, challenging religious views, etc.) [4]. The Scapegoat may also be chosen based on how they challenge authority or point out the dysfunctional patterns in the family [1, 6]. They are often the family member who is reacting most honestly to the dysfunction around them. They may be the one who refuses to pretend that everything is okay.

When there is a family member who has a tangible concern that brings strain on the dysfunctional family system, that makes the child more likely to be chosen as the Scapegoat. Other family members may feel the child needs the most help, therefore they are the biggest issue [2]. When more focus is already placed on the child, it is easier to put more blame on them, further alienating them from the family system [7].

Long-term Effects of Growing Up as the Family Scapegoat

Growing up as the blamed child, the Scapegoat may become an adult who struggles with their relationships with others, especially with authority [8]. The Scapegoat can grow to have trust issues and may not believe others have their best interest at heart; they may be hesitant to be vulnerable or intimate with others in fear they will be treated the same way they were growing up [7]. 

This blame causes daily emotional abandonment from those in the child’s life who are meant to care most about them, and love them unconditionally [3]. When a child is blamed long enough, they often stop questioning the blame and start questioning themselves, their worth [7]. These beliefs can lead to self-sabotage. The Scapegoat may seek out relationships that mimic these patterns in platonic, work, and romantic relationships [7]. 

Scapegoated children may develop co-dependent tendencies in their relationships, finding responsibility in managing their partner’s thoughts, feelings, and actions. They may sacrifice their own needs in order to fulfill their partner’s in an attempt to gain their love and acceptance [3]. This tendency toward co-dependency is a form of fawning, a reaction of their nervous system in survival mode. 

The scapegoated child may grow to resent their family, themselves, and in-turn, isolate themselves further [7]. They may feel the need to constantly defend themselves, existing in survival mode. They may over-explain themselves to avoid blame, or assume people will misunderstand them. The constancy of living in this heightened state can develop into symptoms of Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (C-PTSD), especially if other manipulative and destructive tactics are utilized (e.g., gaslighting, villainizing) [7]. 

These negative narratives that have been spoken over them their entire life can become the framework for how they view themselves. The Scapegoat can begin to believe that they are “worthless,” or “broken,” or “the problem.” When a child is buried in criticism and judgment, they will naturally have emotional reactions to this maltreatment. In an environment where these emotions are not accepted or safe, the child may turn them inward [3]. 

One of the biggest pieces of collateral in the Scapegoat dynamic is the child’s feeling of self-worth. Low self-worth and intense experiences of shame and guilt can lead to anxiety, depression, and feelings of inadequacy [7]. Many scapegoated children can grow up to not fully know who they are as a person outside of the perception of family members [6]. 

What Healing Looks Like

Parents of the Scapegoat

Parents of the Scapegoat, it isn’t too late to mend this damage. There are a number of ways to create healing in the family dynamic when there is a Scapegoat present: 

• Take Accountability

There is healing in speaking the truth out loud. The Scapegoat often comes to be because of the avoidance of uncomfortable feelings. When parents take accountability for this avoidance and genuinely acknowledge that the Scapegoat is carrying things that they were never meant to carry, healing can be possible. 

• Do The Work

The Scapegoat often develops because of the unresolved trauma in the family unit. Parents of scapegoated children, this means you. It is normal for unresolved trauma to be reenacted, that does not make it okay. Seeking help and guidance in a therapist can be a great place to start.

Many of these scapegoating dynamics exist because of the avoidance of uncomfortable feelings. Learning how to sit with discomfort, failure, conflict, and honesty can allow healing to happen. 

• Accept Boundaries

Forgiveness may not be immediate, if ever present, in the healing journey with a scapegoated child. This repair can be offered through consistency, change, and boundaries. The scapegoated child may need space, distance, or silence from the family dynamic that brought so much harm. Allowing them the space to heal is honoring.

The Scapegoat

You deserve healing. None of this was ever your fault. The narratives those who were meant to love you put on you are not true. You might not know how to get out from under them. You don’t have to do it alone. 

• Setting Boundaries

The Scapegoat deserves boundaries, especially when they were rarely given. When the scapegoating dynamic is present, it is not a reflection on the child and their worth, but on the family’s dysfunction. It is okay to set boundaries with family, especially if they are not in a place to acknowledge the damage done [1].

• Reparenting Yourself

There can be so much healing in providing oneself with care, love, acceptance, and attention that was lacking in childhood [7]. Getting to know their own needs, healthy ways to self-soothe, and discovering their strengths can be healing for the Scapegoat. 

Exploring their identity outside of the family narrative can be a great way to grow. It can be healing to explore hobbies or interests that may have been dismissed by family members. Then, the Scapegoat can decide for themselves if it is something worth doing [1].

 Note: This is one of the biggest roadblocks in the Scapegoat’s healing journey. It can be difficult and feel wrong to intentionally seek themselves after being the family’s problem their whole life [8]. You are so worth knowing. It is not selfish to get to know yourself.

• Therapy & Community

Healing happens in community. Reconnecting with others can help the Scapegoat overcome the isolation and lies told to them by their dysfunctional family unit. Finding who they are among others can bring healing and growth. This community can be found in support groups, friendships, and other professional communities, such as a therapist [1]. A therapist can help the Scapegoat challenge and identify the narratives that have been woven into their identity. 

Family therapy would be beneficial for this broken dynamic, though it is doubtful that the family would agree to attend sessions [6]. 

Final Thoughts

The problem child. The bad apple. The punching bag. The rebellious one. The difficult child. The family scapegoat. Whatever name was given to you, it was never the truth of who you are.

It may have felt like you couldn’t do anything right. You may feel rotten, broken, or completely at fault. You are worth so much more than these lies that were spoken over you. You don’t have to do this alone. Healing is difficult, it can feel wrong, and completely isolating. But it is worth it, you are worth it. You were never meant to carry an entire family’s pain alone. 

If any of this is resonating with you, whether you’re the scapegoated child or the parents realizing that maybe this is something you did or are doing, and you’d like to speak with someone about it, we have a team of wonderful therapists and coaches here at the Journey and the Process who would love to walk alongside your healing journey. You don’t have to go it alone and healing is possible. We would love to walk with you! Reach out below for a free, 15-minute consultation today.

Did you miss the last blog? Grab it here!

References

[1] Alpern, P. (2024). The family scapegoat: A symptom of dysfunction. Center Psychology Group. https://www.centerpsychologygroup.com/2024/12/12/the-family-scapegoat-a-symptom-of-dysfunction/ 

[2] Embark Behavioral Health (2025). Dysfunctional Family Roles: Identifying and Addressing Them. Embark Behavioral Health. https://www.embarkbh.com/treatment/therapies/family-therapy/dysfunctional-family-roles/ 

[3] Kindera, J. (2023). Codependency & Trauma–The scapegoat unmasked. CPTSD Foundation. https://cptsdfoundation.org/2023/11/28/codependency-trauma-the-scapegoat-unmasked/ 

[4] Mandeville, R.C. (n.d.). Healing from family scapegoating abuse: The power of naming the unseen. Family Scapegoating Abuse (FSA) Recovery. https://www.scapegoatrecovery.com/what-is-family-scapegoating-abuse/ 

[5] Mimms, K. (2023). Family scapegoat: Signs, effects, & How to cope. Choosing Therapy. Medically reviewed by Kristen Fuller, MD. https://www.choosingtherapy.com/family-scapegoat/ 

[6] Schwartz, A. (2025). Toxic families and the scapegoat role. Mental Health. https://www.mentalhealth.com/library/toxic-families-navigating-the-challenges-of-being-a-family-scapegoat 

[7] Smith, A. (2024). From blame to empowerment–Healing as the family scapegoat. Boston Post Adoption Resources. https://bpar.org/from-blame-to-empowerment-healing-as-the-family-scapegoat/ 

[8] Wright, A. (2026). The golden child: The burden of being the ‘easy’ one. Annie Wright. https://anniewright.com/golden-child-high-achieving-women/ 

The post The Family Scapegoat: Understanding the Black Sheep Role and How to Heal appeared first on Tabitha Westbrook.

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) has become an easy target in online trauma spaces, and some of that criticism is earned. CBT is structured talk therapy built around the link between thoughts, emotions, and behaviors, and it is heavily researched and widely covered by insurance. The problem starts when people treat CBT like a universal solvent for suffering. Trauma is not just a “thinking problem”; it lives in the nervous system, in attachment wounds, and in the body’s survival responses. If therapy ignores felt safety, minimizes real harm, or rushes to “challenge thoughts” while someone is still in danger, CBT can feel cold, overly intellectual, and invalidating. Done well, though, CBT becomes a practical tool inside a larger trauma-informed therapy plan.

What is helpful about Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?

A core strength of CBT is helping people notice automatic thoughts, especially automatic negative thoughts (often called ANTs). Many trauma survivors can “spiral” at lightning speed, jumping from a stressor to catastrophic outcomes because the brain is trying to predict threats and self-protect. Slowing that process down is powerful: noticing the thought, checking whether it is accurate, and choosing what to do next. CBT also gives language for what is happening in the mind, engaging the prefrontal cortex (our thinky thinky parts) so we can make meaning rather than being carried by alarm signals alone (our feely feely parts). The key nuance is that some negative thoughts are accurate. If you are in an abusive or coercively controlling relationship, fear may be a wise signal, not a cognitive distortion. Therapy must honor reality, increase safety, and support the body, not argue someone out of valid danger.

That is where “third wave CBT” approaches can shine, especially dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT). DBT skills such as mindfulness, emotion regulation, distress tolerance, and interpersonal effectiveness can give trauma survivors options when their nervous system is overwhelmed. ACT adds room for values, acceptance, and committed action when life is hard and pain is real. Most importantly, these approaches can integrate somatic therapy concepts: what you notice in your body when a belief shows up, where shame lives physically, and how the nervous system shifts during stress. Many clinicians also pair cognitive work with body-based trauma methods like EMDR, brainspotting, internal family systems, and somatic experiencing, which help reprocess traumatic memories and the negative beliefs attached to them.

What is Trauma-informed Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?

Trauma-informed CBT takes into account what we know to be true about trauma and doesn’t bypass pain or minimize the harm someone has experienced. A trauma-informed CBT mindset also respects faith without spiritual bypassing. For people who connect mental health and Christian faith, identity beliefs matter deeply, but not in a “take two verses and call me in the morning” way. The whole person – mind, body, and spirit – is tended to in the healing process. As we often say here, we are not just brains on a stick.

If trauma planted the belief “I am worthless,” true healing will involve both cognitive and somatic work: naming the belief, tracking sensations, understanding where it came from, and gradually moving toward a truer, grounded belief about worth, safety, and strength. Practical tools include tracking thoughts, urges, behaviors, emotions, and sensations to find patterns before a harmful coping strategy takes over. When you can see the ditch your mind keeps flowing into, you can start backfilling it with new skills, support, and safer choices over time. Cognitive behavioral therapy is not the whole answer for trauma, but used wisely, it can be a valuable healing tool and a steady, empowering part of whole-person trauma therapy.

Your Next Best Step

We are passionate about providing the best, most comprehensive care to those who are healing. If you want to learn more about the whole-person therapy and coaching we offer or want to connect with one of our amazing therapists or coaches, reach out today for your free, 15-minute consultation. We’d love to help you heal and be your truest, most whole self.

The post Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and Trauma appeared first on Tabitha Westbrook.

Coercive control is a much better name for domestic abuse, domestic violence, or interpersonal violence because many people still picture abuse as only physical or sexual violence. The reality is that coercive control is a sustained pattern of power and control that slowly erodes another person’s autonomy, agency, and sense of self. It can look “subtle” or even invisible on the outside while feeling suffocating inside the relationship. The core issue is not conflict or a “bad marriage,” but a repeated system where one person’s preferences, needs, and voice get treated as irrelevant. Understanding coercive control helps survivors name what is happening, trust their perceptions again, and begin rebuilding safety, dignity, and emotional clarity.

A key distinction is the difference between a one-off hurtful moment and a repeating pattern. Everyone can speak sharply or act selfishly at times, then feel guilt, repair the harm, and take responsibility. To put it mildly, we can all be jerks now and again. Coercive control, by contrast, repeats and escalates. It often includes grooming behaviors that present as charm, devotion, or protectiveness while narrowing the victim’s choices over time. Many survivors describe a “captivity funnel” effect: the relationship starts wide with freedom and slowly tightens through pressure, dependency, and fear. Common tactics include gaslighting, rewriting reality, minimizing, and convincing the victim that their memory is unreliable, which can create chronic anxiety and constant self doubt.

Coercive control also shows up through spiritual abuse in Christian contexts, when someone weaponizes faith, Scripture, or religious authority to demand compliance. It can sound like “God wants you to submit” or “don’t question the Lord’s anointed,” especially when the controlling person is a pastor, leader, or highly respected figure. This fosters dependency and isolation by implying that safety and belonging require silence. Other coercive control behaviors include monitoring phones, location, and finances; restricting access to food, clothing, healthcare, or work; cutting off friends and support systems; and using emotional punishment like the silent treatment or withdrawal of affection to force behavior. Over time, the victim’s world becomes smaller and the cost of disagreement feels dangerously high.

Consent is another critical area. Sexual coercion can occur without overt force, including persistent badgering, guilt, threats of withdrawal, or spiritualized pressure about “wifely duties.” Assent is not consent; true consent is freely given and enthusiastic without manipulation. When a person cannot control their yes because they are worn down or afraid of consequences, that is not a genuine agreement. Naming these dynamics matters because coercive control thrives on confusion. Survivors often ask, “How did I get here?” The answer is usually incremental escalation paired with tactics that keep the victim off balance.

Coercive control is not only psychologically damaging; it is physically harmful. Chronic stress changes the body through neurochemicals and inflammation, increasing risk for health problems over time. That is why we are adamant that all abuse is physical abuse, even when no one is hit. If you suspect coercive control, don’t panic. Get curious, gather data, and think about safety, because asking questions and setting boundaries can increase risk. Seek support from trained advocates and therapists who understand domestic abuse dynamics. If you fear you may be the controlling person, change is possible but requires ownership, accountability, and individual work rather than couples counseling. The path forward involves radical honesty, repentance, and sustained effort to become a safe person who no longer needs control to feel secure.

Don’t go this alone. Reach out today for your free, 15-minute consultation. We are here to help heal – whether you are the controlled or the controller. One of our amazing therapists or coaches is happy to walk with you in healing.

The post Coercive Control Deep Dive appeared first on Tabitha Westbrook.

The hidden habits that keep us stuck — and the mindful shift that moves us forward.

We spend a lot of energy trying to win stuff like arguments and situations. We often have an inner monologue running constantly in our heads. But winning and being effective are not the same thing. In fact, the drive to be right is one of the biggest obstacles standing between us and the peaceful, purposeful life God promises, and also can really mess up relationships.

This week we dig into the seventh principle of mindful connection: effectiveness. This isn’t about productivity hacks or life optimization. It’s about something far more personal — learning to do what actually works, in a way that moves you toward your goals, your relationships, and ultimately, toward God.

Over years of working with clients — and doing my own inner work — I’ve seen the same pain points come up again and again when it comes to living effectively. Let’s walk through them together.

The Pain Points Standing in Our Way

These are the most common struggles that come up when we talk about effectiveness. Thankfully every single one has a way through.

“As Brené Brown said, ‘Clear is kind.’ If we are responding to what we think we should be, or what the situation should be, then we’re missing out on information and connection opportunity.” — Tabitha Westbrook

What Effectiveness Actually Looks Like

Being effective is not about being perfect. It’s not about getting everything right the first time. It’s about purposeful movement — doing what works, in this moment, toward the goal in front of you.

That requires a few things: knowing what your goal is, responding to what’s actually happening (not what you think should be happening), and being willing to adapt how you pursue that goal when something isn’t working.

Psalm 139 is an invitation to honest self-examination — not condemnation, but rather it’s about getting clarity. Asking God to search our hearts, including for willfulness, is one of the most effective things we can do. We can’t change what we don’t know and we all have things we need to adjust from time to time. It positions us to respond to reality rather than our own story about reality. I was super heartened by a leader I respect a great deal sharing a story where he’d recently made a mistake and had to make repair and figure it out. I myself had to evaluate the way I respond in stressful situations when I realized my response in a particular situation showed me an area I was not as effective as I’d have preferred. None of these situations are meant to slam us into the pavement and tell us we’re horrible. This isn’t about shame when we ask God to show us stuff. What they do is help us grow and refine and see those areas where we can grow in our ability to be effective. Think about it this way, a loving parent looks at us and goes, “Hey, that’s probably not gonna take you where you want to go. Would you like to try something different? I can help you out.”

A Few Ways to Practice This Week

Effectiveness is a skill, which means it takes practice. Here are some ways to build it intentionally:

• Notice the “right vs. effective” moment. When you feel the pull to win an argument or dig in your heels, pause. Ask: what am I actually trying to accomplish here? Does being right get me there?
• Set a SMART goal. Pick one area of your life — a habit, a relationship pattern, a practice — and make it Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Realistic, and Time-bound. Ask: what could get in the way, and how will I address that proactively?
• Try “willing hands.” Sit comfortably and place your palms face-up in your lap. Notice what shifts in your body and your mind when you physically open your hands. It’s a small gesture with a surprisingly powerful effect.
• Check your TUBES. Before reacting to a situation, scan your Thoughts, Urges, Behaviors, Emotions, and Sensations. This brief check-in can create just enough space to choose effectiveness over reactivity.
• Ask for help. Identify one area where you’ve been trying to go it alone. Reach out — to a friend, a coach, your therapist, or God in prayer. We need each other.

A Word on Grace

As with everything, we hold effectiveness alongside grace. There is no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus (Romans 8:1). That means this work — noticing our willfulness, seeing our own blind spots, and, when needed, adjusting our approach — is not about shame. It’s about real freedom and growth.

The goal was never perfection. It’s mindful connection — with ourselves, with others, and with God. And effectiveness, practiced with compassion and intention, is one of the most powerful pathways to that connection.

The post How to Be Effective appeared first on Tabitha Westbrook.

Hi, I’m Tabitha and I’m a recovering perfectionist. I say recovering because it’s an ongoing process, sometimes a rather frustrating one if I’m being honest.

Perfectionism is sneaky. It disguises itself as high standards, as diligence, as caring deeply about doing things well. Before you freak out and say, “Hi, we need to have some standards here” let’s flesh out what I mean. High standards and care aren’t the issue; it’s what underlies those standards. There’s a relentless inner voice that keeps a running tally of every misstep, every shortcoming, every way you didn’t quite measure up today. That voice has a favorite word:

Should.

I should be further along. I should have handled that better. I should be more patient, more productive, more consistent, more spiritual, more everything. And underneath all of that shoulding is the unspoken belief that if you just judged yourself hard enough or tried harder, you’d finally become the person you’re supposed to be. And sometimes that shoulding is encouraged by environments we exist in—maybe our home or even our church community.

Here’s what I know after years of working with clients and walking this road myself: that belief is not true. And the connection between perfectionism and anxiety is far closer than most people realize.

What “Shoulding” Actually Does to You

In therapy, as you’ve seen above, I use this phrase: shoulding on yourself. And before you laugh — or wince — let me tell you why I use it deliberately. Because it captures something true about what harsh self-judgment actually does. It doesn’t clean things up, it actually just makes a mess.

When we should on ourselves, we are essentially telling ourselves that reality is wrong. That the way things are is unacceptable or not enough or wrong. And here’s the problem with that: saying something should or should not have happened doesn’t change the fact that it did. It also doesn’t mean whatever standard we’re applying is accurate. All it really does is add a layer of shame and self-condemnation on top of whatever already happened or whatever we’re trying to accomplish.

Perfectionism and anxiety are deeply linked because the perfectionist mindset is fundamentally future-focused and fear-driven. It’s not just I want to do well. It’s If I don’t do this perfectly, something bad will happen — I’ll be exposed, I’ll disappoint people, I’ll lose something important. It also indicates a standard, and we don’t always stop to explore where we got that standard from and whether it’s reasonable or not. That underlying fear keeps the anxiety engine running constantly, even when there’s nothing actually wrong.

And when we inevitably fall short of the impossible standard the negative self-judgment kicks in. And this, of course, fuels more anxiety. Which fuels more perfectionism. It’s a cycle that feeds itself, and it is exhausting. It’s for sure not a good time.

Has Harsh Self-Judgment Ever Actually Worked?

I want to ask you something directly: Has judging yourself harshly ever produced lasting change in your life?

I’m not asking whether it has ever motivated you temporarily. Sometimes shame and self-criticism do produce short bursts of behavior change. But lasting change, the kind that actually sticks and becomes part of who you are? I have never, in all my years of practice, seen harsh self-judgment produce that.

Think about it this way: if shoulding on yourself worked, I literally would not have a job. We would all just judge ourselves into excellence and go about our days. But that’s not what happens. What actually happens is that we judge ourselves, feel shame, either shut down or overcompensate, fall short again, judge ourselves again and the cycle continues.

The harsh inner voice isn’t making you better. It’s keeping you stuck. And the perfectionism and anxiety it fuels are not a sign of high standards, they’re a sign of rigidity and potentially past wounds that need some healing.

Pride Goes Both Ways

Here’s something that tends to surprise people: thinking too lowly of yourself is just as much a form of pride as thinking too highly of yourself. Both are a form of self-focus that pulls us out of the present moment and out of genuine connection, with others, with our work, and with God.

When we are deep in the perfectionism and self-judgment cycle, we are living on autopilot (if you’ve been reading along with these past blogs, you know that autopilot doesn’t help us get where we want to go). We reacti to an internal critic rather than responding to what’s actually in front of us. We are so consumed with measuring, evaluating, and finding ourselves lacking that we can’t be fully present in our own lives. We miss what’s actually happening because we’re too busy running the internal audit.

Romans 8:1 says it plainly: “Therefore, there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.” Not a little condemnation. Not condemnation except for the really big failures. No condemnation. The inner voice that keeps up the running tally of your shortcomings is not the voice of the Holy Spirit. It is not godly conviction. It is condemnation and it is not from God.

The Difference Between Conviction and Condemnation

I want to make an important distinction here, because I know this is an area where well-meaning Christians can get real confused at times. There is a difference between godly conviction and the shame spiral of perfectionism and self-judgment.

Conviction is specific. It points to a particular thought, action, or pattern and invites you toward something better. It is ultimately hopeful. It says, “This can change. You can grow. Come this way.” And then it moves on.

Condemnation is global. It doesn’t point to a behavior, it indicts your whole self. It says, “You are the problem. You are not enough. You will never be enough.” It doesn’t invite you toward growth. It pins you to the floor.

Perfectionism lives in the condemnation space. And it is worth learning to recognize the difference, not so you can ignore genuine growth opportunities, but so you can stop letting a voice that isn’t God’s (or even your own voice at times) run your internal life.

The Grace-filled Alternative to Perfectionism and Anxiety

So if harsh self-judgment doesn’t work, what does? This is the part I love, because the alternative is not lowering your standards or giving yourself a pass on everything. It is something much more powerful and far more nuanced than that.

There is an essential truth that I come back to again and again, both in my own life and in my work with clients. It holds two things together at the same time: I am doing the best I can in this moment, and I can do better. Both are true. Neither cancels out the other.

This is what theologians call sanctification—the ongoing process of being changed into the likeness of Christ. We are redeemed and we are being changed. We are accepted as we are and we are not yet who we will be. There is no room for condemnation in that process. This is the essence of the now and the not yet.

Practically, this means replacing the should with something more honest and more useful. Instead of “I should be further along,” try: “I wish I were further along, and I’m going to take one step today.” Instead of “I should have handled that better,” try: “I didn’t handle that the way I wanted to. What can I learn from it? Do I need to make a repair with someone?” The facts stay the same. The shame is removed. And the path forward opens up.

Mindful Connection: The Antidote to the Perfectionism Spiral

One of the most powerful tools for breaking the perfectionism and anxiety cycle is the practice of mindful connection. As a reminder, that’s being fully present in the moment rather than lost in the internal audit of everything you’re doing wrong. We keep our feet in this present moment instead of the shoulding of it all.

When we are present we’re able to observe what’s actually happening without layering judgment on top of it. We can notice: I made a mistake. Full stop. Not: I made a mistake, which means I’m a failure, which means I can’t be trusted, which means… Just the facts. Just the moment. Just what is.

This is not lowering the bar. This is seeing clearly. And seeing clearly, without the distortion of perfectionism and self-judgment, is actually what makes genuine growth possible. You can’t address what you can’t see accurately. And you can’t see accurately when shame is clouding the lens.

Progress, Not Perfection

I say it constantly: mindful connection, not mindful perfection. Progress, not perfection. And I say it constantly because people — especially perfectionists (including me) — need to hear it constantly. Because the inner critic is loud, and the grace-filled alternative feels unfamiliar at first.

But here’s a big take away I want you to understand: choosing progress over perfection is not giving up. It is not settling. It is not a spiritual or personal cop-out. It is the only framework in which real, lasting change actually happens. Because change requires trying, and trying requires the willingness to be imperfect in the process.

There is only one perfect person. His name is Jesus. And He didn’t come to give us a higher standard to fail at; He came to set us free. That freedom includes freedom from the tyranny of the should. Freedom from the perfectionism and anxiety cycle that keeps so many of us exhausted and stuck. Freedom to show up, imperfectly and fully, and to grow.

You are not a project to be managed. You are a person to be loved.

I invite you to stop shoulding on yourself. It isn’t working anyway. This week I invite you to take one of the more gracious positions I outlined in this blog and try it out for yourself. Notice whether it’s easier or harder depending on the topic or situation. Notice what you feel in your body as you get curious. And if you need a little support with it, reach out to us for a free, 15-minute consultation. One of our fantastic therapist or coaches would be happy to help you build these skills and those new neural pathways that go with them!

Ready to break the perfectionism and anxiety cycle and find a more grace-filled way forward? Visit tabithawestbrook.com/online-courses to learn more about the Taking Every Thought Captive course series. Use code RESET24 for 80% off.

The post Perfectionism and Anxiety: Stop “Should-ing” on Yourself appeared first on Tabitha Westbrook.